Challenging Cleveland’s Free Speech Zone

Bennett L. Gershman writes for the Huffington Post about the ongoing controversy over Cleveland, Ohio’s imposition of a free-speech zone in advance of the upcoming Republican National Convention. Cleveland city regulators have created a 3.5-square mile area dubbed the “Event Zone,” and are restricting parades, demonstrations, and speech-making anywhere in the zone.

The regulations require anyone wishing to exercise expressive rights within the zone to acquire a permit, which Gershman points out is a generally unconstitutional form of censorship known as “prior restraint.” He also argues that even in situations where a city government may have a compelling interest in maintaining public safety and trying to combat traffic congestion, it is still essential for that government to respect the First Amendment rights of its citizens by narrowly tailoring its regulation to allow the exercise of broad speech rights.

Gershman does note that the ACLU has successfully challenged the Cleveland speech zone on First Amendment grounds, resulting in a federal district judge ordering the city to modify its regulations. As of yet, however, these particular modifications have not been revealed, leaving the public unclear as to what limitations may still be placed on speech around the convention.

Restrictions on speech like those causing controversy in Cleveland can be dangerous to free speech because they stifle the ability of protestors to peaceably assemble, and they further contribute to, and indeed officially sanction, a culture of coercive intolerance towards those who disagree with prevailing attitudes or whose ideas are considered particularly troubling.

More Blog Posts

02-10-2020 05:11pm

Warrior for the First Amendment

Ashley Messenger didn’t plan on being a First Amendment lawyer. “It was an accident,” says Messenger, who is a senior associate general counsel with National Public Radio in Washington. But 20 years into her career, she’s worked with some of the most high-profile organizations in media and has watched how the industry and its environment has evolved along with shifts in technology and society.

Read more

04-16-2019 11:37am

New Survey Reveals American Consumers Support Businesses Hiring Those with Criminal Records

New research from SHRM and the Charles Koch Institute found that the vast majority of American consumers support purchasing goods and services from businesses that employ people with non-violent criminal records.

Read more

04-04-2019 03:05pm

On 70th Anniversary of NATO, Key Member States Question Its Relevancy and Efficacy

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) celebrates its 70th anniversary, and in advance of this historical commemoration, a new survey asked respondents in key NATO member states about NATO’s effectiveness and relevance in today’s world.

Read more

Sign up for updates