Free Speech Protections Extend to Private Boycotts

The Los Angeles Times editorial board writes about the increasing presence of the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement in the United States,  a controversial effort to boycott the nation of Israel until it ends its involvement in Palestine. Some BDS supporters accept the possibility of a “two-state solution,” but others do not.

In response to the BDS movement, which is increasingly criticized as a platform for anti-Semitism, some state governments are passing laws refusing to make contracts with any business engaged in a boycott of Israel.

The LA Times argues that such laws are both unnecessary and troubling attempts to stifle political speech. Moreover, it is not government’s role of to censure a person or a company, or to deny them access to a benefit or contract for which they otherwise would be eligible, simply because that person or company holds the “wrong” opinion on an issue.

When government uses the force of law to denote which side of a heated debate is the “correct” one, it ends the public discourse on that issue and stifles the speech of those who hold the “wrong” ideas. This further entrenches the “wrong” ideas in the minds of those who hold them and suppresses the important public dialogue that might eventually change people’s current views.

Conversely, those who would engage in a boycott should also consider how that decision comports with the purpose of their organizations. If, as in the case of universities, one of their organization’s goals is an open exchange of ideas, endorsing particular sides in a dispute can hamper a vibrant discussion on campus.

More Blog Posts

10-16-2018 02:10pm

Sensitizing Stories: Rob Wallace

Rob Wallace, an award-winning producer and senior producer for ABC News and CBS News and an adjunct faculty member for the Media and Journalism Fellowship, recounts his career in film and television.

Read more

10-08-2018 08:10am

Occupational Licensing Reforms Remove Roadblocks

New Mexico’s occupational licensing reform shows how making changes at the state level removes barriers to opportunity, especially for low- and moderate income Americans.

Read more

09-25-2018 03:09pm

Pompeo’s On the Right Track with North Korea Negotiations

Mike Pompeo’s move to invite North Korean Minister of Foreign Affairs to DC is in line with the views of Americans and South Koreans.

Read more

Sign up for updates