The Victims of Drug Testing’s False Positives

Jacob Sullum of Reason highlights several cases where police relied on faulty suspicions of drug possession to arrest, detain, and convict people. Furthermore, he writes that thousands of people nationwide have potentially faced similar situations.

Highlighting one example, Sullum explains that sheriff’s deputies in Leawood, Kansas, detained the Harte family for more than two hours after mistakenly identifying the loose tea leaves in the family’s trash as marijuana.

Although, as Sullum writes, “these tests are generally not admissible in court,” because approximately 90 percent of drug cases are resolved by plea deals, that means that potentially tens of thousands of people have been convicted and labeled as felons based on very flawed tests.

For example, a Claflin University biotechnologist tested the “KN reagent” drug test that led to police raiding the Harte family’s home. The biotechnologist found that 33 legal plant products tested positive for marijuana under the KN reagent drug test, including “spearmint, peppermint, basil, oregano, patchouli, vanilla, cinnamon leaf, lemon grass, bergamot, lavender, ginseng, anise, gingko, eucalyptus, rose, cloves, ginger,” and others.

In another example, Sullum highlights the story of a police lieutenant in Hillsborough County, Florida, who found that the NARK II field test could yield a positive identification of methamphetamine by merely being exposed to air.

Stories of such false positives are concerning and demonstrate why law enforcement must ensure they are using reliable drug testing methods while being considerate of the great damage that can be done to the victims of such mistakes.

More Blog Posts

10-16-2018 02:10pm

Sensitizing Stories: Rob Wallace

Rob Wallace, an award-winning producer and senior producer for ABC News and CBS News and an adjunct faculty member for the Media and Journalism Fellowship, recounts his career in film and television.

Read more

10-08-2018 08:10am

Occupational Licensing Reforms Remove Roadblocks

New Mexico’s occupational licensing reform shows how making changes at the state level removes barriers to opportunity, especially for low- and moderate income Americans.

Read more

09-25-2018 03:09pm

Pompeo’s On the Right Track with North Korea Negotiations

Mike Pompeo’s move to invite North Korean Minister of Foreign Affairs to DC is in line with the views of Americans and South Koreans.

Read more

Sign up for updates