Ultimate Arbiters: A Conversation on the Judiciary’s Pursuit of Justice

This morning, summit attendees heard from Judge Richard Nygaard and Judge Ricardo Hinojosa regarding the range of problems affecting our criminal justice system. The conversation ranged from how federal sentencing guidelines came about to mandatory minimums to overcriminalization to the need for measures that prevent crime before it arises, in particular for youth in impoverished communities.

Hinojosa began by describing sentencing in the federal court system, noting that sentencing guidelines were put in place in order to reduce the amount of variance offenders received in terms of their sentences. However, sentencing guidelines were meant to be just that, guidelines, while preserving important discretion for judges to adjust the punishment to truly fit the nature of a particular crime.

Hinojosa did not express as much concern over mandatory minimums as Nygaard did, but he noted that significant reform is needed to “safety valve” provisions associated with mandatory sentencing guidelines. Allowing judges to depart from otherwise mandatory sentences in a well-specified set of cases could improve the use of a tool in which Hinojosa does see value. Moreover, he expressed support for reducing the length of some mandatory minimums that are too punitive or out of proportion with other crimes in the system.

Nygaard’s issues with mandatory minimums were more unequivocal. He spoke from personal experience about how it chafed to have to apply mandatory minimums in many cases. Nygaard was similarly unequivocal in his views on overcriminalization, affirming plainly that it is a serious problem. While Hinojosa said that he believes there is room to improve the federal criminal system, he stopped short of deeming the problem to be one of overcriminalization, per se.

Among questions fielded by the judges were ones about tangible reform proposals for issues with our criminal justice system. To learn more about how you can get involved and submit your ideas, please visit the Charles Koch Foundation’s Request for Proposals page.

05-20-2020 01:20pm

StoryCorps Connect During COVID-19: Finding a New Way to Share America’s Stories

StoryCorps pivots to digital to keep building connections between people during the pandemic.

Read more

05-19-2020 05:39pm

Free speech provides comfort during COVID-19 pandemic

Trying circumstances can also present opportunities for people to come together. When people feel as if they face a common challenge, differences and divisions begin to blur. That’s cause for optimism.

Read more

05-14-2020 11:20am

Five steps for public officials to protect public health, regain public trust, and ensure civil liberties during COVID-19 crisis

Americans and their public officials grapple with the dynamic while working to protect public health and maintain the public confidence necessary for successful adoptions of temporary measures and ultimately restoration of their full civil liberties. Charles Koch Institute Senior Fellow Casey Mattox offers advice on the subject.

Read more