Why Reform the Criminal Justice System?

Though we may have arrived at our current criminal justice system through the actions of many well-meaning individuals, far too many of its features run counter to the basic principles of a free society.

The United States currently incarcerates 2.2 million people, at a rate of over 700 for every 100,000 residents. Somewhere between 70 million and 100 million Americans have a criminal record, which acts as a barrier to employment and other opportunities following release. Because children who have a parent behind bars are more likely to end up in prison themselves, our system is harming both this generation and the next.

Many of the system’s flaws begin in the U.S. Code, which contains more laws than anyone could be expected to read or understand. The absence of a clear definition of a “crime” has made counting the number of crimes on the books nearly impossible. The latest count puts the number at over 4,500. That, of course, does not even include the over 300,000 regulatory violations that carry criminal penalties. Many of those laws do not contain a mens rea requirement, meaning an individual who commits a crime without intending to can be found guilty nonetheless.

Furthermore, the use of militarized policing tactics and  equipment creates deep tensions between law enforcement agents and the communities they police, endangering both and creating a sense of insecurity. Other problems emanate from civil asset forfeiture laws, which sometimes incentivize law enforcement to act in ways that threaten the rights of innocent individuals, and mandatory minimum sentencing laws, which impose unduly harsh and counterproductive punishments, often on nonviolent offenders.

Overwhelmingly, these policies have led to increased incarceration, which consumes a significant portion of state and federal budgets. Corrections spending represents the third-largest category of spending for most states, and over 20 percent of the Department of Justice’s budget.

But incarceration is costly in more than just dollars and cents. The collateral consequences of a criminal record make it difficult for ex-offenders to successfully re-enter society. Occupational licensing laws bar ex-offenders from performing certain jobs, regardless of their expertise or experience, and hiring policies discourage employers from hiring ex-offenders. Further, incarceration is an especially expensive public safety solution given that while crime has been falling for the last 25 years, less than one-third of that reduction is explained by rising incarceration rates.

To better understand the key issues involved in engendering such a system, the United States will need to close gaps in research, identify policy solutions, and overcome resistance to reform. The Charles Koch Institute’s Advancing Justice summit in New Orleans this week will gather leading figures in the reform movement to discuss these issues and spur both research and action that will enhance public safety and human dignity.

More Blog Posts

04-01-2021 07:38am

Order and chaos: Embracing an emergent order mindset

We are surrounded by order that occurs without design or control on all sides. Yet we rarely think about this order.

Read more

03-24-2021 08:16am

Supporting the emerging generation of tech leaders

An employer and associate perspective from the Emerging Tech Policy Leaders Program, which received 90 applications for its first cohort.

Read more

03-18-2021 08:42am

Where should K-12 go next?

We ask two of our partners in K-12 education to tell us what they’ve learned in the last year, and what they think should happen next.   

Read more

Sign up for updates